What if the systems we use to manage student behavior are actually working against us, and against our students?
In this four-session book study, participants will engage with Alfie Kohn's landmark Punished By Rewards to critically examine the reward and punishment frameworks that dominate classroom management practice. Through collaborative discussion and reflection, participants will explore why external motivators like sticker charts, clip charts, prize boxes, and consequence ladders may produce short-term compliance while undermining student autonomy, intrinsic motivation, and classroom community.
Participants will also examine why reward and punishment systems are widely recognized as inconsistent with trauma-informed practice, and how compliance-based approaches can erode the trust and safety students need to thrive, and what we can do instead.
There are 4 synchronous meetings via Zoom for this book study that equal 6 hours. The other 3 hours are for work completed outside of these sessions to read, reflect and prepare. No partial credit and attendance is required for all sessions.
*The text is available from our lending library. If you would like to borrow this for the book study, please complete a lending form on our website by July 8, 2026.